How we count

The four labels

Every fact on this site carries one of four labels, always written out in words.

Label	What it means
Primary source	We checked it ourselves at the place it comes from, for example the publisher or the page we link. The label is about the source; this site itself is unofficial.
Per reviews	Taken from a review published by the named outlet.
Community-confirmed	We read it ourselves at a fan source (a forum poll or fan market), or two independent fan sources say the same.
Unverified	We only know it from one second-hand report and could not check it at the source. Treat it with care.

The review log

• By hand only. Someone types each row in from the outlet’s own review page. We do not copy numbers from Metacritic, OpenCritic or other aggregators; we link to them.
• Score as printed. We copy the score and the scale exactly: 9/10, 4.5/5, 95/100.
• Out of 100. Score divided by scale, times 100, one decimal. 4.5/5 becomes 90. 8.5/10 becomes 85.
• No number, no count. Verdicts like “Recommended” or letter grades are listed in words but not counted. We would rather leave a gap than guess.
• Median, average, range. All use every score in the log, with equal weight. The median is the middle value: half the scores are higher, half lower. It is not a Metascore.
• Times are shown in Central European Time (CET). Rows added in the last 24 hours are marked “new”.
• Corrections are made in the row, which then shows the date of the fix.

Call your score

• The slider lets you pick a score from 50 to 100. It is compared with the middle of each documented forecast (“higher than 3 of 4 forecasts”) and, once reviews are in, with the median of the reviews in our log.
• Forecast bars span the scores a forecast allows. Where a source gives a split instead of one number, we use the range that holds the middle vote, or the outcome with more than 50 %.
• Your card is drawn in your browser. Your call is stored only on your device and never counted. See Your call.

Each chart has a “How to read this” note and a text version for screen readers.

Who called it?

Once reviews are in, each forecast gets a verdict against our median: “spot on” when the median falls inside the forecast’s range, otherwise the distance in points to the nearest end of that range. We do not compare against aggregator scores, because we do not copy them.

Community vote (from January 2027)

The vote opens in January 2027. Before the first vote counts, the full rules go here: one vote per person and category, limits against duplicates and bots, and the number of counted votes next to every result. No votes are collected before that.

What we never do

• No own gameplay, screenshots or video.
• No leaked material.
• No Rockstar Games logos, key art or trailer stills, no rating-board marks.
• No ads, no affiliate links, no cookies, no betting links.

Who writes this

Texts are written by the editorial team. Drafts may be prepared with AI writing tools; every page is checked against its sources and approved by the person responsible named in the legal notice before it goes live. Found a mistake? Please write to the email address there.